I don’t know whether people still read Orwell’s 1984. But I expect most of my readers know it. Remember what Winston Smith’s job was, at the Ministry of Truth?
This feels as if Trump is ordering the Ministry of Truth to rewrite history, and it’s not going so well.
I think the Morning Joe team did a good job of capturing the current situation. As did Philip Bump in today’s Washington Post. See Trump finds himself on the wrong side of a conspiracy theory: He has leveraged conspiracy theories for a decade—and now one lumps him in with The Elites:
One of the common misunderstandings about President Donald Trump is that he created the culture of conspiracy and surreality in which the American right is now immersed. He didn’t. He simply leveraged it.
This isn’t to say Trump hasn’t generated or amplified any conspiracy theories. He obviously has. It is simply meant to note that he emerged as a political figure a decade ago from an existing culture in which such claims were common currency. The central advantage Trump possessed in the 2016 Republican presidential primary was that he was willing to agree with false theories in a way that the established politicians against whom he was running were not. His most identifiable issue, immigration, was and is rooted in false claims about foreign powers shipping criminals to the U.S. where they are subverting traditional America. It’s conspiracies all the way down.
The conspiracies that take hold of the right centrally rely on the idea that Elites Are Up To No Good. In any objective context, Trump himself would be considered an elite, given his billions of dollars and his power, even before being elected president. But Trump sided with The People, meaning those beside him in the conspiratorial swamps. Because he stood against The Elites, a loosely bounded group that ostensibly controls America — meaning The People — Trump was granted a seemingly irrevocable dispensation from elitism.
Now, that dispensation is suddenly looking rather wobbly.
The reason? Jeffrey Epstein, the man who encapsulated so many of the characteristics that the conspiratorial right attributes to The Elites: inconceivable wealth, access to powerful politicians and celebrities, a privileged lifestyle (including a private island!) and accusations of criminal sexual deviancy involving minors. All of that was attributable to Epstein even before his 2019 death in a Manhattan jail cell — a suicide that was quickly presented by conspiracy theorists as something far more suspicious.
By the time Trump announced his presidential candidacy in mid-2015, Epstein was already a felon. The muckraking website Gawker had already published the contents of Epstein’s address book, including more than a dozen phone numbers for Trump and Mar-a-Lago, where Epstein had once been a regular. The site also published logs from Epstein’s private jet; Trump (and former president Bill Clinton) had been passengers multiple times.
But Epstein wasn’t really an issue in the 2016 election.
The salience of Epstein increased once Trump was president, and not only because it was during this period that the disgraced businessman was arrested and died. Trump’s first term in office saw the emergence of a sweeping conspiracy theory about an undercover government employee who was helping Trump conduct a secret, global campaign to uproot a cabal of pedophiles whose membership included various celebrities and (Democratic) politicians.
This was QAnon, which helped explain (as one adherent explained to me at the time) why Trump’s tumultuous, disorganized administration was actually a secret success. The pattern that Trump had leveraged since 2015 appeared again: What appeared to be, wasn’t; what was, was hidden from view.
QAnon caught on. In May 2021, PRRI found that nearly a quarter of Republicans believed in even its most extreme presentation, that “the government, media, and financial worlds in the U.S. are controlled by a group of Satan-worshipping pedophiles who run a global child sex trafficking operation.” QAnon’s adherents were a central element of the effort to overturn the 2020 election during the riot at the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021. When Trump left power two weeks later, QAnon dissipated somewhat — though that was in part because its precepts and themes were absorbed and adopted by various right-wing actors, including Trump.
Epstein became a cudgel for the right to use against Trump’s replacement, Joe Biden. It’s much easier to espouse and amplify conspiracy theories when you don’t have the power to rebut them. Allies of Trump’s, like his son Donald Trump Jr. and then-Sen. JD Vance (R-Ohio) suggested that there was some nefarious reason that the government wasn’t sharing more information about Epstein, including a theorized set of clients or files in which various other Elites would be implicated.
The idea became so ingrained among Trump’s supporters that the existence of this material was treated as established fact and its release an inevitable element of a second Trump term. He and his allies would be asked about the material and (with a few notable exceptions) would pledge that it would be made public.
And then Trump became president.
There were other places where Trump’s return to the White House put him in a somewhat unsteady position. His advocacy for coronavirus vaccines in his first term had soured in the right-wing media universe since leaving office, for example, but that was easily remedied by tapping one of the country’s foremost anti-vaccination advocates to run the government’s health agencies. Epstein, though? Much harder to circumnavigate.
It probably didn’t help that Trump’s allies, like Attorney General Pam Bondi, weren’t interested in undercutting the right-wing narrative. Early on, she insisted that she was in possession of a client list that was being vetted. Then she — or someone at the Justice Department — attempted to put the whole thing to rest by inviting right-wing social media influencers to the White House and giving them mostly the stuff that had been published by Gawker a decade prior. The pro-Trump right wasn’t satisfied.
Last week, the Justice Department took another approach, releasing a memo flatly rejecting the idea that there was any client list to share. When a reporter attempted to ask Bondi about the memo at a Cabinet meeting, Trump interjected.
“Are you still talking about Jeffrey Epstein?” he asked. “This guy’s been talked about for years.”
Rumors swirled that senior FBI officials disagreed with the approach — officials who’d often touted conspiracy theories in their prior careers as Trump-aligned right-wing commentators. On Saturday, Trump published a lengthy message on Truth Social defending Bondi and offering a novel explanation for what had happened with the Epstein material: The “client list” conspiracy theory was itself a function of a left-wing conspiracy.
“Obama, Crooked Hillary, Comey, Brennan, and the Losers and Criminals of the Biden Administration, who conned the World with the Russia, Russia, Russia Hoax, 51 ‘Intelligence’ Agents, ‘THE LAPTOP FROM HELL,’ and more … created the Epstein Files, just like they created the FAKE Hillary Clinton/Christopher Steele Dossier,” Trump wrote, invoking various other conspiracy theories he had helped establish as canon on the right.
There are three fundamental challenges for Trump here.
The first is that he doesn’t have the control over conspiratorial thinking that he thinks he has. Again, he piggybacked existing anti-elite theorizing to reach the White House. As the vaccine debate shows, he’s never fully controlled it.
The second is that he is now president. As an expert on conspiracy theories explained to me back in 2017, the powerful have a difficult time leveraging conspiracy theories because those theories are generally tools used to rebut power (like that of The Elites). Presidents could prove a conspiracy theory true, if it were, but cannot prove one false since they are part of a system enmeshed in the theory.
The third, and most important, is that there are unanswerable questions about Trump’s relationship with Epstein. Trump was friends with Epstein. Trump and his family appear multiple times in Epstein’s address book, the only “list” that’s known to exist. Not only can the Justice Department never adequately dismiss a conspiracy theory that centers on government power; Trump is perhaps uniquely powerless to fully dismiss a conspiracy theory with which he is intertwined.
We can assume that the Epstein issue will soon fade from relevance in the national conversation, granting Trump a reprieve from the consternation of much of his base. (The replies to his post on the social media platform he owns have been broadly and unusually disparaging.) However, we can still recognize this moment for the exception that it is: Probably for the first time since he announced his candidacy in 2015, Trump has found himself on The Elites side of the divide against The People. Instead of leveraging the power of conspiratorial thinking, for at least a moment, he is seeing it being used against him.
Given how dependent his political power is on the grip with which he holds his base, even the loosening of one finger may be a weakness he can’t afford.
A Final Ray of Sunshine
Imagine how much worse things would be if Pam Bondi had any sense.
Facing MAGA 